log(book)
Cover of Under One Banner.

Under One Banner

author: Graydon Saunders
series: Commonweal #4
date read: 2021-06-04
pages: 344
lists: fantasy
rating: โ˜… โ˜… โ˜… โ˜† โ˜†

The series started dropping off for me a bit here: I didn’t find the protagonist compelling, and her recovery from an active magic user to a military adviser only as interesting as the world it exposed. But the focus on military matters didn’t interest me for the most part, so I focused on the implicit bits of civilian worldbuilding (I loved those, to compensate).

For example: Necromancers are highly useful, since they can sterilize large amounts of matter, particularly water. Or: to argue complicated cases, 15 judges split in teams of 5 judges, and everybody argues for the view they least support. Also: more gender worldbuilding, in that some human races construct their gender based on the concepts of “creative” and “supportive”. The whole gender and pronoun thing gets some more explanation, as does the “races of humans living together”, which is very neat: It was mostly ignored before, but clearly there looking back. Proves careful thought on Saunders’ part (though nobody can claim he doesn’t overthink things, to be fair).

Oh, and the language, of course. Military slang is even better than civil servant slang, in this world, and “comprehensive alteration of terrain contour” was particularly nice.


54/ Under One Banner by Graydon Saunders. A drop in quality, but still nice worldbuilding. Only worth it if you enjoy the series a lot. https://books.rixx.de/graydon-saunders/under-one-banner/
54/ Under One Banner by Graydon Saunders. A drop in quality, but still nice worldbuilding. Only worth it if you enjoy the series a lot. https://books.rixx.de/graydon-saunders/under-one-banner/ #rixxReads

Related books Books related to the whole series are linked at the first part of the series.